Wood-Burning vs Gas Fire Pit: Which Fits Your Backyard?

Updated October 28, 2026 · Research-based guide

Disclosure: We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. We have not physically tested these products. Our picks come from published specs, manufacturer documentation, and buying criteria explained above. How we make money.

A fire pit is one of the cheapest ways to make a backyard feel like a destination. Before you pick a model, though, the first choice is fuel: wood or gas. That one decision changes your budget, where the pit can go, how much upkeep it takes, and whether your HOA or local rules will even allow it.

This guide walks through the trade-offs so you can decide before you spend anything.

The short answer

Choose wood if you want crackle, smell, real heat, and the lowest upfront cost, and you have room to keep it well away from the house.
Choose gas (propane or natural gas) if you want instant on/off, less smoke, easier placement near a patio, and you're fine paying more upfront.
Not sure? Check your HOA rules and local burn rules first. They often make the decision for you.

1. Upfront cost

Wood-burning pits span the widest range. A basic steel bowl is the cheapest way in. Smokeless-style double-wall steel pits cost more, and a built-in masonry or paver ring varies with materials and labor.

Propane fire tables and pits usually cost more than a comparable wood bowl, because they include a burner, an igniter, and a housing for the tank.

Natural gas often has the highest total cost even when the unit itself is similar. The expense is running a gas line, which usually means a licensed plumber or gas fitter and often a permit.

Prices change constantly, so treat any number you see online, including on this site, as a starting point. Get a written quote for any gas-line work.

2. Heat and feel

Wood fires generally put out more radiant heat and have the look and sound many people picture when they think "fire pit." Gas flames are steadier and tidier, but many propane fire tables are more about ambiance than warmth. If you plan to sit outside on cold winter nights, check the BTU rating on any gas unit and read the manufacturer's notes on heat output.

3. Smoke and neighbors

Smoke is the biggest everyday complaint about wood pits. It follows you around the circle, gets into clothes, and can drift into neighbors' windows. Double-wall "smokeless" designs reduce smoke once the fire is hot. They don't eliminate it, especially at startup or with damp wood.

Gas produces little visible smoke. On a small suburban lot with houses close together, that alone can settle the question.

4. Placement and safety distances

Placement matters more than the model you choose.

Wood pits: the model International Fire Code says recreational fires shall not be conducted within 25 feet of a structure or combustible material (IFC 2024, Section 307.4.2). For portable outdoor fireplaces it sets 15 feet, but exempts those used at one- and two-family homes (Section 307.4.3), so follow the manufacturer's manual. Your local fire code may differ, so check with your fire marshal. Never put one under a pergola, covered porch, or low tree canopy.
Gas units often allow closer placement. Follow the manufacturer's listed clearances exactly, and keep them out of enclosed spaces.
Surface: set any pit on a non-combustible base such as pavers, gravel, or concrete, never directly on a wood deck unless the product is specifically rated for it.

Before you buy, measure the actual distances in your yard: from the pit spot to the house, the fence, and the nearest branches. If the only spot that meets wood-pit clearances is far from your patio, gas may be the more practical choice.

Planning tip: sketch the patio, seating circle, and pit on a simple grid before you buy. (Our Etsy shop has printable planners for this. They're our own products.)

5. Rules: HOA, county, and burn bans

This step is easy to skip and expensive to get wrong.

HOA covenants may ban open wood fires, require approval for permanent structures, or set placement rules. Read your covenants and ask the architectural committee before you install anything permanent.
Local burn rules: some areas restrict open burning on certain days or during dry spells. Rules vary by city and county, so check with your local fire marshal for current guidance.
Gas lines usually need a permit and a licensed installer.

Gas units are sometimes allowed during burn restrictions when wood fires aren't. Confirm that locally instead of assuming it.

6. Upkeep and running cost

Wood: you need a dry, covered place to store firewood, plus ash cleanup after most fires. Buying split, seasoned wood adds a recurring cost. Use local firewood rather than hauling it in from far away, to avoid spreading pests.

Propane: you'll refill or swap tanks, and a tank can run out mid-evening. Keep a spare if you use it often.

Natural gas: no refills, the lowest hassle long term. You only pay for the gas you use, and the installation cost is mostly behind you once it's in.

7. Cooking

Want s'mores, hot dogs, or a grill grate over the flames? Wood is the natural fit. Many gas fire tables say in their manuals not to cook over them, because food drippings can clog burners. If cooking matters to you, read the manual before you buy.

Side-by-side summary

Factor	Wood	Propane	Natural gas
Upfront cost	Lowest to moderate	Moderate	Highest (gas line)
Heat	Strongest	Low to moderate	Low to moderate
Smoke	Yes	Minimal	Minimal
Placement flexibility	Least	More	More (fixed spot)
Upkeep	Wood + ash	Tank swaps	Very low
Cooking	Yes	Usually no	Usually no
Burn-ban risk	Higher	Often lower*	Often lower*

*Confirm with your local authority.

What to look for when shopping

Whichever fuel you choose, compare these specs instead of star ratings:

Material and thickness: heavier-gauge steel or cast stone lasts longer outdoors, especially in humid climates.
Spark screen and cover (wood): a screen cuts flying embers, and a cover keeps rain out of the bowl.
BTU rating and ignition type (gas): higher BTUs mean more flame and heat. Electronic ignition is more convenient than a match-lit burner.
Safety certification (gas): look for a recognized listing, such as CSA, in the product specs.
Tank storage (propane): a hidden tank compartment looks cleaner but limits the tank size.
Warranty: compare the length and what it actually covers, especially for burners.

Our take

For most suburban yards, the decision comes down to two things: how close the pit will sit to your house and neighbors, and what your HOA allows. If you have space and permission, a wood pit gives the most fire for the money. If space is tight, smoke would bother you or your neighbors, or your HOA prefers it, a propane fire table is the easy, flexible middle ground. If you're already planning a bigger patio project with a contractor, ask them to quote a natural gas line at the same time. It's cheaper to do it then than to come back later.

Plan it before you buy it

Fire pits work best as part of a whole plan, together with the seating, the path from the house, lighting, and shade. If you're mapping out a bigger backyard project:

Browse the printable planners and budget spreadsheets in our Etsy shop (our own products).
Want to see your yard made over? The Backyard Oasis app is in development. Join the waitlist to get early access.

Last reviewed: October 2026. Prices, product availability, and local rules change. Always confirm with the manufacturer and your local authorities before you install.

Shop these picks on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Prices change, so check current pricing on Amazon.

Plan it before you buy: our planners and budget spreadsheets are in our Etsy shop (our own products).